Can I Have a High IQ and Make Dumb Decisions – It’s a Balancing Act

Has a recent encounter with an intelligent person left you shaking your head in disbelief? Or do your friends quickly point out your unreasonable behavior or mistakes because they know you have a high IQ?

You will be surprised to learn that you can have a high IQ and still do dumb things. This is because intelligence is multifaceted, and a high IQ is one of its facets. So, yes, you can be dumb while having a high IQ score

IQ is not necessarily an indicator of being effective in making smart decisions, so no one is safe from doing stupid things, even the best of us. Interestingly, some people with high IQ may seem “socially stupid” because of their inability to understand social cues and interactions. Many highly intelligent people simply consider social interactions unworthy of their attention. In fact, there is a hypothesis referred to as “clever sillies”. According to it, people with high IQ tend to overanalyze social problems, which often results in poor common sense responses. 

In a world where IQ is viewed as the ultimate measure of intelligence, it's easy to beat yourself up for acting dumb. A high level of intelligence may mean something other than brilliance in every aspect of life. A high IQ, in particular, is only one facet of intelligence.

No one can know everything in the world, and some people with a high IQ may lack self-awareness and self-reflection and believe that they know everything about everything. 

This leads to having many blind spots and overconfidence in their abilities, making them more prone to errors in judgment. These blind spots can manifest in various ways, such as failing to recognize personal biases, underestimating the complexity of certain situations, or dismissing the value of others' opinions, which makes people with high IQs look dumb in the eyes of others.

To provide a more comprehensive answer to the question, "Can someone have a high IQ but be dumb?" we'll explore the place of IQ, the test's shortcomings in measuring rational thought, and, of course, whether an individual can truly be intellectually gifted and still do dumb things.

You May Also Like: Why Do I Feel Like a Failure

Can You Have a High IQ and Be Stupid?

Thinking of yourself or others as stupid can seem demeaning, but human stupidity exists. Carlo M. Cipolla, a Professor of Economics at UC Berkeley, in his book The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity, defines stupid people as persons who cause losses for themselves and others for no gain and probably suffer losses too. Put, stupid people's actions are devoid of common sense and end up harming other people and probably themselves—all for nothing.

Unfortunately, stupidity does not discriminate based on intelligence. Based on experiments carried out in universities across the globe, the good professor concluded that you would find a fraction of stupid individuals among blue-collar workers, white-collar workers, students, professors, and even Nobel laureates!

IQ Hits and Misses on Human Intelligence

Historically, IQ scores have had their place in measuring intelligence; for example, they provide information about a person's capacity to apply knowledge to answer questions and make predictions. A high IQ can play a role in academic and professional success, especially in areas where grasping information and deductive reasoning with speed are required.

And yes, taking an IQ test can give you a better understanding of your cognitive abilities, like learning, memory, and reasoning capabilities. Traditional intelligence tests place most people in the average range and a small fraction of people in high intelligence levels (and even fewer at the genius level). 

That said, human intelligence is broader than a single test score. 

As a multifaceted concept, it encompasses other aspects such as "street smarts" and emotional intelligence to navigate social interactions and solve everyday problems effectively.

As David Perkins from Harvard Graduate School of Education in Cambridge puts it, IQ is like the height of a basketball player. While height is good, more factors are required to make them a great basketball player.

Overall, IQ tests don't measure creative, emotional, and practical intelligence, even though these play a big role in forming everybody's behavior, including people with high IQs. This gap can explain why some people with high IQs still make decisions that seem dumb or out of touch with reality. Without these other forms of intelligence, even the most intellectually gifted can struggle with everyday challenges, leading to mistakes that seem surprising given their cognitive abilities. 

So, Is a High-IQ Person Also Smart?

High intelligence does not necessarily equate to smartness. 

A smart person can connect knowledge and insights with other types of intelligence, like emotional intelligence, to navigate everyday problems. They win society's admiration because they can offer smart, out-of-the-box ideas that solve complex problems efficiently. 

Think of a smart person as one who sees what others can't easily see and, with their brilliant knowledge and ideas, makes the impossible possible. 

You May Also Like: 12 Things Dumb People Do That a Smart Person Wouldn’t

Am I Dumb? A Witty but Revealing Question for People With High IQ

This brings us to the next question. Despite your high IQ, can you feel dumb?

The answer is Yes. But surprisingly, it may have nothing to do with your IQ. 

Let's explain.

It all goes back to the reality that intelligence is multifaceted. You may have outstanding prowess in understanding abstract knowledge and analyzing complex data but flop in other areas of your life. A classic example is perhaps the people we call "nerds".

A large percentage of people who excel in academics may find social interactions or business negotiations tough and emotionally draining. Based on this premise, society will easily label them incompetent—not because their high IQ is in doubt but because they exhibit a lack of emotional intelligence.

Let's digress a bit here. If you've been asking yourself, “Can you have a high IQ and be bad at school?” First of all, that's a valid question. It's no surprise that students with high IQs struggle in school, get poor grades, or encounter other tremendous difficulties.

However, these difficulties are more likely to be connected to other factors, such as disinterest, an undiagnosed learning disability, ADHD, slow processing speed, or low self-efficacy. Figuring out what problem is plaguing you and solving it will help you adjust accordingly.

Now, back to addressing stupidity, Professor Cippola theorizes that the probability of an individual being stupid is independent of any other characteristics of the individual. He acknowledges that genetics may have a small part to play, but he emphasizes, based on many years of research and observation, that the power of nature, not education or intelligence, is responsible for the stupid people in circulation. 

Embracing Smartness: How a Person with High IQ Can Let Go of Stupidity

"Does anyone know when the 5 o'clock news starts?"

Hilarious, right? Probably to other people but not you. One of your college friends may be blunter and quip, " For someone with your IQ level, your stupidity is appalling."

If this is the story of your life, here is some good news. You can appear less dumb if you make the right changes.

David Dunning, a Psychology Professor at the University of Michigan, suggests that a stupid person can only remain so if they deliberately refuse to acknowledge the behavior gaps and work towards fixing them. Your high IQ gives you the capacity for creative solutions, but if you have deficits in your communication and emotional intelligence, your brilliant ideas may not matter much.

Consider improving your critical thinking and decision-making skills. Combining your high intellectual abilities with smartness will enable you to stop acting dumb.

Here are a few tips to let go of being stupid:

1. Acknowledge you may exhibit some stupidity.

Even the smartest people in the world can make mistakes and feel stupid from time to time. Unfortunately, many people with high IQs also suffer from perfectionism, and take allow blunders to hit harder than they should. High standards are okay, but not when it impacts your self-esteem.

2. Don’t act superior or judge others for being “less intelligent.”

Acting better than others because of your intelligence is not a smart decision. Don't live under the assumption that everyone is an idiot except you. That is dumb and dangerous. Take a dumb test if you need to, and then strive to improve your approach to life.

3. Keep an open mind.

Surround yourself with reasonable people and allow them to challenge your ideas occasionally. That way, you'll gather insights that improve your actions. Openness to new perspectives fosters cognitive growth and helps you avoid the pitfalls of rigid thinking, ultimately leading to more balanced and informed decision-making.

4. Lean on other people.

Many people with a superior IQ underestimate the importance of social interactions, believing they can handle everything on their own. However, this mindset can limit your growth. You can't judge your incompetence effectively by yourself. Lean more on others to learn about your deficiencies and find ways to overcome them. Collaboration and seeking input from others can be key to refining your decisions and actions.

5. Understand the destructive power of stupidity.

Acting dumb or making stupid decisions does not benefit you or others in the long run. Stupidity, in this context, refers to the stubborn refusal to recognize errors or adapt when needed. Ignoring this can lead to repeated mistakes and missed opportunities, ultimately hindering your success.

6. Practice self-awareness.

Above all, practice self-awareness and strive to learn more about yourself. Taking a personality test, for instance, can help you understand your strengths and weaknesses and why you do things the way you do. This deeper understanding of yourself will allow you to make more conscious decisions, leveraging your intelligence without falling into the traps of thoughtless actions.

Focus on The Future: You Can Always Be Better

Sure, you may have acted or made several dumb decisions, but there is always hope. First, be kind to yourself. It sets the stage for learning from your mistakes and forging ahead.

Remember, there are many different types of intelligence, and intelligence can always be improved. Your high IQ is a significant and positive gift. All you have to do is intertwine it with other aspects like emotional, social, and practical intelligence to enjoy the success you deserve.  

Recommended Reading 

• Cognitive Health and IQ: What Does Your Intelligence Say about Your Mental Fitness?
• Keeping Your Brain Young: 10 Ways to Keep Your Brain Healthy and Slow Cognitive Decline